Collections/Hotels That Don't Feel Like Hotels

Hotels that don't feel like hotels.

No lobby to speak of, no front desk shift change, a room count you can hold in your head. Restored houses, farmhouses, and inns under fifteen rooms where the experience is closer to borrowing a place than checking into one.

  1. Great Barrington, MA · $$$ from $445

    5 rooms. Five rooms, Michelin Key, run by former New York restaurant pros. George Bailey's house, sort of.

  2. Harwich, MA · $$$ from $425

    8 rooms. An adults-only 8-room inn on the Cape Cod Rail Trail — heated pool, loaner bikes, full breakfast.

  3. Nags Head, NC · $$ from $255

    6 rooms. A 1940s cypress-shingle B&B across the dunes — six rooms, adults-only, Jockey's Ridge views.

  4. Bar Harbor, ME · $$$ from $445

    10 rooms. On an 80-foot cliff above Frenchman Bay — 10 adults-only rooms, private beach stairs, hot tub.

  5. Galena, IL · $$ from $215

    5 rooms. An 1845 Greek Revival mansion — five rooms, walking distance to Main Street.

  6. 6Bobcat Inn· 8.2
    Santa Fe, NM · $$ from $275

    8 rooms. A 1960s adobe on 10 high-desert acres south of town — eight rooms, courtyard fire pit, coyote-country quiet.

  7. Volcano, HI · $$ from $285

    5 rooms. Five cabins-in-the-rainforest at Volcano Village — adults-only, walking distance to Volcanoes National Park.

  8. Brewster, MA · $$ from $295

    9 rooms. An 18th-century sea captain's home, restored in 2016 by its New York owners. AAA Four Diamond, 2025.

  9. Lenox, MA · $$ from $325

    9 rooms. A 1874 Prohibition speakeasy turned nine-room boutique, run by Kelly and Bryan Binder. Café on the ground floor.

  10. 10Mt. Ada· 8.1
    Avalon, CA · $$$$ from $895

    6 rooms. The 1921 Wrigley family's mansion above Avalon — six rooms, the only hotel with a chimney on the island.

  11. 11Holualoa Inn· 8.1
    Holualoa, HI · $$$ from $545

    6 rooms. Six adults-only rooms on a 30-acre Kona-coffee estate — built by the Inaba family in 1978.

  12. Whitefish, MT · $$ from $285

    9 rooms. Nine rooms in a Craftsman-revival lodge — the Whitefish design-set's pick.

  13. Lenox, MA · $$$ from $475

    6 rooms. A restored farm near Tanglewood — three rooms in the main house, a cottage, a schoolhouse. Quiet.

  14. Healdsburg, CA · $$$ from $545

    10 rooms. A 10-room farmhouse inn on working cattle land — farm-dinner ethos, 20 minutes from Healdsburg plaza.

  15. Beaufort, SC · $$ from $285

    7 rooms. An 1790 plantation house on Bay Street — seven rooms, riverfront porches, family-owned.

  16. Wilmington, NC · $$ from $215

    7 rooms. An 1893 Queen Anne on the Cape Fear River — seven rooms in the historic district.

  17. Greenport, NY · $$ from $335

    4 rooms. An 1870 Dutch Colonial summer home with four rooms and serious harbor views. Proper porch.

  18. Mendon, VT · $$ from $325

    14 rooms. Reopened June 2024. A restored 1840s farmhouse on 13 acres, minutes from Killington.

  19. Elk, CA · $$$$ from $895

    11 rooms. A 1916 redwood-built oceanfront inn — 11 rooms, Two-Michelin-Star restaurant, Forbes 5-star.

  20. Hilo, HI · $$ from $285

    5 rooms. An 1899 Hilo mansion that hosted Queen Liliuokalani — five rooms, Shipman family-owned for 6 generations.