Bellport, NY · Hamptons

Bellport Inn

Seven rooms above a village restaurant on the quiet, unfashionable side of the bay — the anti-Hamptons Hamptons stay.

Plan a stay
8.0/10Very good.How we score
Why we’d stay

A refined Americana interior, in a historic inn. Google guests rate it 5.0★ across 156 reviews.

Best for
a romantic weekendfamiliestime on the water
Not for
anyone who wants room service and resort amenities
Best time to go

Late May through September for the water; September in particular, when the crowds thin and the ocean's still warm.

Our verdict

Very good. Priced well under what it delivers.

Rate
from about $255/night
See rates & dates →

We earn a small commission if you book through this link, at no cost to you. How this works

Bellport Inn is a refined americana hotel in Bellport, NY, part of the Hamptons. Seven rooms above a village restaurant on the quiet, unfashionable side of the bay — the anti-Hamptons Hamptons stay.

It sits in our Refined Americana category, occupying a historic inn, with a romantic · country mood. 7 rooms. Independently owned and operated.

On the property

  • Activities: PADDLE.

A full review is still ahead

We haven’t published our first-person write-up of Bellport Innyet. When we do, it’ll land in the same voice as our Piaule, Troutbeck, and Inness reviews. In the meantime, the facts on the right and the tags above will tell you most of what we know.

See similar hotels: more Refined Americana hotels · every Hamptons hotel · more historic inn conversions

The Le Hotelist Score
8.0/10
Very good.
Assessed September 2026
Design7.2

A refined Americana interior, in a historic inn.

Location7.1

A quiet spot near the center of things.

Service9.4

Google guests rate it 5.0★ across 156 reviews.

Value8.5

In line with the mid-luxury field (from about $255/night) for the room, setting and design you get.

Quiet8.0

Under 10 rooms.

Based on the data we have so far; expect small revisions as guest reviews and our editorial deepen.

How we score hotels →