The Reform Club
Seven rooms and a private-club energy in the middle of Amagansett. The rare Hamptons hotel that actually feels like a clubhouse.
The Reform Club is what happens when a hotelier stops trying to compete with the Hamptons' noise and instead copies the English country-house playbook. Seven rooms, a private library, a bar that only guests can drink at, two acres of Amagansett just off Main Street. There is no sign. You find the front door by knowing where it is.
The aesthetic is collected: oak floors, Turkish rugs, 19th-century art pulled from the owners' own walls, velvet where velvet belongs, an actual fireplace in most rooms. Breakfast is served at a long table in the parlor. The pool is behind hedges. The bar looks like it belongs at a London club and functions that way too — conversations, not DJs.
$895 a night is the price. You're not paying for square footage. You're paying for the seven-person-capacity theater of a Hamptons weekend done correctly.
Who it's for: Couples doing a third anniversary. Anyone who finds Gurney's exhausting. People who would rather not be photographed at their hotel.
Who it's not for: Bachelorette parties. Families (kid-friendly on request, not by design). Guests who want high-volume social scenes — the Reform Club will feel too quiet by half.
