The list.
9 hotels matching your filter · 510 in total
Region · Finger Lakes
Northeast24
Mid-Atlantic & South22
Mountain West & Southwest16
Pacific & West Coast20
Islands & Outliers8
Northeast
9 hotels
Belhurst Castle
An 1889 Richardsonian Romanesque stone castle on Seneca Lake — 29 rooms, on-site winery.
Geneva On The Lake
A 1911 Lamoreaux Landing-era villa on Seneca Lake — 30 all-suite rooms in formal Italianate gardens.
Inn at Gothic Eves
Eight rooms between Cayuga and Seneca — a Victorian B&B that takes its breakfast seriously.
Inns of Aurora
Five restored 19th-century houses along one Cayuga Lake village main street, run as a single quiet resort by the woman who created American Girl.
Morgan Samuels Inn
Stone mansion on a working farm — six bedrooms, fireplaces, three-course dinners by request.
Taughannock Farms Inn
An 1873 Victorian estate overlooking Cayuga Lake — 16 rooms, restaurant with Finger Lakes wine program.
The Black Sheep Inn & Spa
An octagonal 1859 house turned wine-country inn — seven rooms, a spa, and properly eccentric decor.
The Lake House on Canandaigua
2020 new-build on Canandaigua Lake — the Finger Lakes' most ambitious design hotel, Condé Nast Hot List 2021.
William Henry Miller Inn
A 19th-century Ithaca downtown inn — nine rooms, whirlpool tubs, walkable to Cornell.